Seven Myths Of The Spanish Conquest Pdf

Here is an intriguing exploration of the ways in which the history of the Spanish Conquest has been misread and passed down to become popular knowledge of these events. That the Conquest was achieved and completed in record time, vini, vidi, vinci style.

Were it not for them, they probably wouldn't have been successful. Matthew Restall has written a serious and important book, but one that is also delightful as it addresses issues about the Spanish conquest that have long intrigued scholars.

Navigation menu

Account Options

For historians, his focus on native voices may be valuable, but his bias toward them should be considered. It's too bad so few will read this because of its scholarly tone. Another aspect of the disunity is that, had the Spanish not conquered the different parts of the Americas, who is not to say the Aztecs would have done similar? American Historical Review. The origins of these and other popular conceptions are examined and I enjoyed discovering some of the reasons these and other stories gained traction over the last few centuries.

He lives in State College, Pennsylvania. The topics it discusses are key in re-examining the ossified legends of the Conquistadores. All these men hoped to receive rewards from the Spanish crown after they had conquered particular areas and proved that this land was rich in gold and of interest to the Spanish Monarchy. However, his search to compensate for attention to Spanish documents by focusing on native documents may swing the pendulum too far the other way. That's why we read and learn and and learn and read some more.

According to Restall, these men were not visionaries but part of a long tradition of exploration. Provocative if dry essay in New World historiography, gainsaying a large body of received wisdom.

The men who joined the expeditions were not soldiers. His topic choices are unwieldy in some cases, such as splitting the myths of completion and desolation into two chapters and neglecting to devote a chapter to the myth of Spanish divinity on its own.

Few had any previous military experience in the Old World. Above all, what one may profit from reading this book would have to be a clearer understanding of the surreptitiously and higgedly-piggedly way in which the conquest was achieved. Restall seems to be simultaneously addressing popular misconceptions and historical misinterpretations of the Spanish conquest. While their actions were definitely commendable, they were not isolated.

Seven Myths is an excellent, how to compress pdf files to email perfectly-paged analysis of the Spanish Conquest and the many misconceptions the average person has concerning this complicated history. Seven Myths of the Spanish Conquest offers a richer and more nuanced account of a key event in the history of the Americas. It emcompasses the seven myhts.

Each chapter takes on a common myth about Africa and explains both the sources of the myth and the research that debunks it. In spite of that growing body of sophisticated research, however, misperceptions and inaccuracies persist, particularly in the English-speaking world. There were actually thousands of African slaves and Native allies that aided the Spaniards. Elizondo's mestizaje and Gutierrez's preferential option for the poor arose out of a theology of context, a theological method that takes seriously the contextual circumstances of their locale. It's an important book, but it suffers from some poor writing, non-great flow.

Interestingly that changed the tone of a few paragraphs, especially when the Spanish were slave-hunting for the silver mines. Professor Restall, in a short, single volume, moves the English-speaking audience well along the road to a more accurate understanding of the Spanish Conquest of the New World. Restall writes in a concise, easily-understood manner, and I breezed through the book like a bag of potato chips. This Very Short Introduction deploys the latest scholarship to shatter and replace the traditional narrative.

Eye-opening were the freedmen, erstwhile slaves, who actively participated in the land-grab. He did discuss Far Side comics and The Road to El Dorado Disney movie, but is that really the most important show of modern impact of Spanish conquest myths? Restall also references movies and comic books, among other elements of pop culture, to show how these myths linger and spread over time.

Seven Myths of the Spanish Conquest by Matthew Restall (ebook)

His refutation of various myths covers most of the book, and they are interesting, well-written and informative. Nonetheless, Spanish writers of the time persistently portrayed the Americas as fully conquered.

There are four more myths that I am a bit too lazy to mention but all of them are enlightening. Restall clarifies the somewhat confusing relationship between the conquistadors and the Spanish crown.

That said, I am glad that it was dusted off the shelf and read from start to finish just recently. It sometimes is a bit too academic, and trying to include all sides, when sometimes it should just make a point! The author adeptly and efficiently lays out the myths and provides appropriate detail for discernment, and by the end, the book feels as though it were a much longer work. One of the reasons that history still has relevance is how we often base history on myth rather than fact. From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.

See a Problem

He believes that the reasons for Spanish success come from the smallpox virus, Spanish steel swords, native disunity, and the general global theme of expansion of empire. European History Quarterly. It was not all so simple and straightforward as had been argued in the past, and likely is even more complex than as argued here. That there existed miscommunication and language barriers between the Spaniards and the Natives that often led to disastrous consequences.

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website. Personally, I had an issue with the titles of the Myth's because it made the Spanish sound like devious racists out for their own good.

Seven Myths of the Spanish Conquest by Matthew Restall

The book is strengthened by its incorporation of actors and issues representing the African diaspora and African Americans in particular. Seven Myths of the Spanish Conquest.